Rules Matter: Leadership Selection Processes

The day after an election is always a busy one. It signals both the of the end of an electoral cycle and the official start to the next. Newly elected candidates and governments are required to quickly begin the pressing work of transitioning to government. Campaign staff and volunteers begin to pack up the campaign offices they’ve recently called home. And for some parties, the election results will dictate the start of an electoral cycle that will include a leadership election.

The rules and structure of a leadership election can have a significant impact on the results of the race as well as the growth and renewal of a party.  Often, decisions related to the rules and structure of a leadership race comes down to a choice between to trade-offs. Such as the choice between expanding party membership or ensuring long time supporters have the opportunity to participate and the choice between representing regions of traditionally strong support or focusing on expanding to new areas.

Let’s go through a few of the most common leadership selection processes and the trade-offs for each.

One Member One Vote (OMOV)

OMOV has been the chosen structure for a number of leadership races over the past few years. It is typically touted as the most democratic and engaging for grassroots participation. While this method is considered the simplest to administer and understand, it is the least representative structure compared to the format of a general election. Even in the cases where all eligible voters directly elect a chief executive (mayor, president, etc.), a party’s leader represents and a party must support a number of candidates that are not elected in this manner.

In our experience, OMOV often leads to mass signups within distinct communities, limited attention to the overall grassroots, and a general abandonment of weak ridings. This structure has the potential to identify strong influencers and organizers, but not universally across all ridings or districts. The power resides within these voting blocks and ultimately limits the leadership campaigns focus on the grassroots, despite the fact that all members having an equal vote and are able to directly participate.

Weighted OMOV by Riding

Weighted OMOV is quickly becoming the most accepted method for leadership selection, given that it maintains an element of direct democracy, while better emulating the actual true general election format, in that every member is able to vote directly for the leader and that vote counts equally within their riding or district. This method forces leadership candidates to focus on having broad bases of support and strong riding level organization. It also motivates them to put resources into ridings that currently have a weak base of support due to the higher point value each member in those riding carries compared to a riding with a large membership base.

In our opinion, this method has considerable merit and it is obvious why it has gained in popularity as a leadership process structure. In the races we have participated in, it has led to significant signups across all ridings and increased attention to the overall grassroots. The success of potential candidates has typically been tied to their ability to identify strong influencers and organizers universally across all ridings. While this format does better match the electoral system, it doesn’t necessarily include the riding association in the process, nor does it emulate the first-past-the-post, winner-take-all riding/district level election process.

Leadership Convention with Riding Level Delegate Selection

Leadership Convention with riding level delegate selections are still quite common and can be partially incorporated into the selection process or as a means of electing party executives. While it shares many of the characteristics of the Weighted OMOV, it is often criticized for being too expensive and less democratic given that members don’t elect the leader directly. With that said, this method has a number of benefits that shouldn’t be overlooked. Arguably it is the process that best matches the electoral system and is the most inclusive of riding/district associations in the process.

The strengthening of local associations and their respective base of organizers, campaigners, influencers, and leaders, as brought forward through the delegate selection process, is the best opportunity for a party to enhance its election readiness and ensure a member’s connection to their respective riding association. The convention itself creates an opportunity to keep key members of the party together in one venue, under one “tent”, and allow for a regrouping, as one party, after the selection of the new leader.

In short, we believe that the structure of a leadership selection process should closely match the format of a general election at the riding level, where the likelihood of successfully electing representatives can be best influenced. While each party will face a different set of circumstances and goals, these processes should ultimately strengthen and broaden the base of support, organizational ability, and election readiness of a party. The crowning of a leader is just one important outcome of a leadership selection process, and parties will be well served by recognizing this.

By-Elections: More Than an Extra Seat

By-elections provide political parties with an ideal training and testing ground for new campaign messaging, technology and strategies.

Hitting The Doors

Door knocking remains one of the most effective campaign tactics there is, especially with the help of Candidate Cloud’s Engagement Software Platform.